James Arthur Ottinger, 57, of McClure, Ohio, was shot and killed at his home on County Road 6, southeast of McClure, on June 5, 2020. He was described as a jack-of-all-trades who often helped neighbors and friends.

A Henry County Grand Jury later indicted his brother, Randall Ottinger, on a charge of aggravated murder, alleging Randall used a 20-gauge shotgun in the killing. The Henry County Sheriff’s Office, the Bureau of Criminal Investigation and Identification, and the prosecutor’s office handled the investigation. Randall Ottinger pleaded not guilty and was held on a $500,000 cash bond.

The prosecution weighed different sentencing options as the case moved through the courts. James’s death left his community and family grieving.

If anyone knew James or has information about the shooting, please come forward.