On May 14, 2014, 60-year-old John R. Supple Jr., an experienced fisherman from Lewiston, New York, left Wilson Tuscarora State Park in a distinctive 16-foot Starcraft boat fitted with camouflage and a wooden duck blind on the bow. He was seen later that day by another fisherman on Lake Ontario but never returned to shore as expected. He may have been wearing khaki shorts, a green and white jacket or shirt, and a camouflage life vest.

An extensive search covered about 5,000 square miles of Lake Ontario and involved U.S. and Canadian Coast Guard crews, but neither Supple nor any part of his boat was found. After days with no results the official search was suspended. An obituary and a community memorial followed; the circumstances of his disappearance remain unknown and both he and his boat are still missing.

Did anyone on Lake Ontario that day remember seeing his distinctive Starcraft or the duck blind on its bow?