Peggy A. Johnson was about 36 when she disappeared in the late summer of 1995 from Murphysboro, Illinois. Known also as Peggy Cram, Peggy Davis, Peggy Hufstutler, and Peggy Etherton, she was described as a white female, brown hair and eyes, about 5 feet 4 inches and 120–125 pounds, with scars on the bridge of her nose and on her left arm.

That evening she was seen at Gene’s Tavern with two local men and left with them for a coworker’s house in nearby DeSoto. Reports say she continued drinking and passed out at the house. One man later said he offered to drive her home; he claimed she woke en route, wanted food, and exited at a Hardee’s to meet a friend who was walking by. Law enforcement has publicly said they do not believe she made it to Hardee’s. Peggy’s purse was found the next morning in a local unemployment office parking lot. She was never found and is presumed deceased.

The timeline has several disputed elements and the man who reported dropping her off was treated as the primary suspect. If anyone knew Peggy, saw her that night, or has information about the DeSoto–Hardee’s area from late summer 1995, please come forward.