Vincent Marsh, 55, was abducted from his Pleasant Hill Road home in South Fulton, Georgia, on July 16, 2019 while taking out the garbage. His captors forced him at gunpoint to withdraw cash from a Bank of America on Old National Highway; bank surveillance showed him bleeding from the head, consistent with being pistol-whipped. Marsh was later found shot in the head and left in the backseat of a red hatchback, which was driven to Pleasant Ridge and Old National Highway and set on fire. The fire was so severe that dental records were needed to confirm his identity, and a .40-caliber bullet was recovered at the scene.

The case went cold for nearly two years before cellphone data led investigators to two suspects, identified as 31-year-old Anthony Goss and 20-year-old Roy Hill. Both men were already in custody on other violent crime charges when they were linked to Marsh’s killing and were charged with murder, aggravated assault, kidnapping, armed robbery, arson, and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. Did anyone in the area see a red hatchback or notice suspicious activity around Pleasant Hill Road that night?