On the afternoon of November 21, 2020, three men were shot to death at a home on Creek Water Court in Lawrenceville, Georgia. Victims were 33-year-old Steven Andrew Finch, 64-year-old Robert Caverly, and 45-year-old Eugene McClam. Responding officers found one man wounded on a neighbor’s porch who later died at a hospital, another deceased near the front door, and Finch dead in the garage.

Investigators later identified 21-year-old Justice Lusk as a suspect. Evidence presented at trial described Lusk taking an Uber to the residence intending to steal methamphetamine and marijuana, leaving with a bookbag and blanket, attempting to use a Lyft, then running into nearby woods. A K-9 team recovered a bag from a crawlspace containing an AK-47, a handgun, muddy clothing, and a large quantity of drugs. Cell phone and ride-share records linked Lusk to the scene and he was arrested the next day when he returned to retrieve the hidden items.

Lusk testified he acted in self-defense; the jury convicted him on multiple counts including malice murder and felony murder, and he received three consecutive life sentences plus five years without parole. Did anyone in the area know the victims or notice unusual activity around Creek Water Court that day?