Larry A. Fenton, 57, was found dead in his Clearwater, Florida, home on February 3, 2008, the day he planned to watch the Super Bowl. He was discovered lying in a pool of blood with multiple gunshot wounds, including to the back, arm, and neck. The house initially looked ransacked, which prompted investigators to consider a possible home invasion.

Detectives noted inconsistencies in that theory: valuable items such as an iPod, a laptop, and jewelry were left behind, there were no signs of forced entry, and the blood around Larry’s body appeared undisturbed, suggesting he had not been moved. His wife, Rebecca Fenton, told police she had been working out in the detached garage when she found him and reported the scene as a robbery; her behavior in news footage and aspects of her account drew investigators’ attention.

Police recovered a .38-caliber revolver hidden in Rebecca’s car; five spent casings from that weapon matched the number of shots fired. At this stage readers should note what remains unclear: who fired the shots and the full motive. Does anyone have information about Larry, his routines, or the days leading up to February 3, 2008?