Jonathan Jeffery, 25, was killed during a violent home invasion at his Summerside Lane residence in Sarasota, Florida, on December 14, 2014. Three masked intruders forced their way into the house in the early morning, tied up Jonathan and his wife Brandi, ransacked the home, and stole an Xbox, a bag of money, and several cell phones. Before fleeing, one of the intruders shot Jonathan in the back of the head, killing him instantly.

Investigators identified two vehicles fleeing the scene; one was traced to Christian Michael Thomas Theodore, 22. Surveillance footage from a nearby Walmart reportedly showed Theodore and Byron Jones buying camouflage bandanas, gloves, and cable ties that matched items used in the invasion. Theodore was arrested and charged with second-degree murder and armed home invasion robbery, while Jones faced charges as a principal to second-degree murder and Azalea Mendoza was charged with accessory after the fact. A fourth man, Antione Battle, was also found at the scene and was wanted on an unrelated Georgia shooting.

What details about that night or the people involved might help explain how the suspects were linked to the scene?