Thomas Joe Wall, 34, was shot and killed at his San Mateo, Florida, home on January 18, 2015. His wife, Lauren, found him after returning from picking up their children from the grandparents’ house. Neighbors said they heard two gunshots that night but initially thought they were children with BB guns. The Putnam County Sheriff’s Office opened the case as a homicide.

Investigators reportedly explored several leads. Family and reports noted marital problems and an alleged long-distance relationship involving Lauren. Wall held a $600,000 life insurance policy, which drew attention in the inquiry. A landscaper, Charles Chaz Arrants, was said to have received a ride from Lauren that night and to have bought bullets shortly before the shooting that matched the caliber used. No arrests were made and the case remained unsolved through at least 2018, when Cold Justice re-examined the matter and highlighted inconsistencies in Lauren’s actions and statements.

Anyone with information about Thomas Wall, his circle that night, or the people mentioned is asked to come forward.