Harley Wayne Hammers Jr., 37, was fatally shot on September 3, 2014, at a property in Fieldbrook, California. Angel Robin Tully, also 37, was shot and died at the scene. Deputies responded after a 911 call reporting shots fired and a deceased female; Hammers was transported to Mad River Community Hospital and pronounced dead there.

Investigators identified Jason Michael Arreaga, 29, of Lucerne, California, as the primary suspect. He was arrested on September 4, 2014, after being seen driving southbound on US 101 and charged with two counts of murder, held on one million dollars bail. At trial Arreaga pleaded not guilty and testified that Hammers’ estranged wife, Shavonne Hammers, was the shooter. Shavonne Hammers received prosecution immunity and testified that Arreaga shot Hammers and Tully after a day of drug-fueled interactions and an altercation between the groups. The jury deadlocked 9-3 for guilt, producing a hung jury; a retrial was set for December 14, 2015.

Key questions remain about conflicting testimony and the events that led to the shootings. If anyone knew the victims or witnessed the events at the Fieldbrook property on September 3, 2014, please share what was seen or heard.