Tammy Pannirello Palmer, 39, was shot dead outside her Stony Point, New York home on September 24, 2012. After seeing her two children off to the school bus, she was ambushed on the property; investigators say the first shotgun blast hit her arm, the second missed, and a third close-range shot to the chest was fatal. The killing followed escalating family tensions: Tammy and her husband, John Palmer, were estranged and she had obtained a restraining order against him.

Authorities allege Tammy’s father-in-law, Eugene Palmer, lay in wait in nearby woods, fled the scene in his pickup truck, and later visited a sister to confess before abandoning the truck near the entrance to Harriman State Park. A local arrest warrant for second-degree murder and a 2013 federal unlawful-flight warrant were issued. In 2014 a judge awarded Tammy’s children a multimillion-dollar judgment against Eugene’s estate after finding by a preponderance of evidence that he was responsible. Eugene Palmer was added to the FBI Ten Most Wanted list in May 2019 and was removed from that list in July 2022; he remains wanted and his whereabouts are unknown.

Does anyone who lived or hunted around Harriman State Park in 2012 remember unusual activity or sightings that could help locate Eugene Palmer?