Stephen McMahon, 42, was shot in the face outside his Amboy Road home in New Dorp, Staten Island, in the early hours of June 29, 2014. He was taken to Staten Island University Hospital in Ocean Breeze and remained in intensive care for two days before dying of his injuries on July 1, 2014. McMahon worked as a carpenter and had moved to Staten Island from Brooklyn about four years earlier.

An investigation led to the arrest of Steven Bonfiglio of Manalapan, New Jersey. Bonfiglio was indicted on murder, manslaughter, weapon possession and tampering with evidence charges, but in March 2016 a judge dismissed the murder and manslaughter counts after finding that testimony about motorcycle gangs was improperly presented to the grand jury. The Richmond County District Attorney’s Office said it intended to re-present the case; at that time Bonfiglio still faced gun possession and tampering charges. The final disposition of those charges and whether the murder case was re-presented is not stated.

Did anyone in the New Dorp area see or hear anything that night, or does anyone have information about the events outside the Amboy Road home?