On the morning of June 24, 2015, 27-year-old Allashun Clay was driving a BMW convertible in Mount Vernon, New York, with 26-year-old Kevin Shaw as a passenger when the vehicle struck a parked SUV at East Third Street and Warwick Avenue, flipped over, and both men were pronounced dead at the scene. What began as a crash investigation became a homicide probe after examiners found gunshot wounds on both victims; the medical examiner was asked to determine whether the shots or the collision were the cause of death.

Investigators developed a working theory that a third person had been in the car, shot both men, then exited the moving vehicle before the crash. Surveillance from a nearby deli showed the BMW traveling at high speed shortly before the collision. Both men had been at Sue’s Rendezvous earlier that night for a music release party, and police canvassed the area and reviewed footage while seeking witnesses.

Did anyone who was at Sue’s Rendezvous that night or who lives near East Third Street and Warwick Avenue see the BMW, the occupants, or anyone leaving the vehicle?