Olivia DiGrigoli, 21, was fatally shot while seated in a parked car on Lakeway Drive in West Babylon on July 25, 2018. She and her on-and-off boyfriend, 22-year-old Anthony St. Hilaire, were both struck; DiGrigoli was pronounced dead at the scene and St. Hilaire later died at a hospital. Police describe the incident as a double homicide and have not publicly determined a motive.

Suffolk County Police responded at about 11:20 p.m. and the Suffolk County Police Homicide Squad later handled the investigation. Authorities and Suffolk County Crime Stoppers have sought tips from the public and offered a cash reward for information leading to an arrest. DiGrigoli’s family has spoken publicly about their heartbreak and frustration and believes people with knowledge may be reluctant to come forward.

No arrests have been announced and the case remains open. If anyone has information about the shooting, please contact the Suffolk County Police or Crime Stoppers.