On the evening of October 25, 1963, 16-year-old Raymond G. Carey Jr. left his family home on Daniel Boulevard in Bloomfield, Connecticut, telling his parents he was going to a movie. He instead went first to a local bowling alley and then to a Pi Kappa Sigma sorority dance at the Lithuanian Dance Hall on Lawrence Street in Hartford. A witness saw him leave the hall with three other teenage boys after saying he had arranged a ride home, but he never arrived and was reported missing the next morning.

Raymond was a Bloomfield High School junior who played basketball and softball at his church, lived with his parents and younger sister, and had no history of running away. At the time he disappeared he was 5 feet 6 inches, about 130 pounds, with brown hair, blue eyes and a scar on his lip. He wore a dark green sweater over a dark green sport shirt, black pants and gray suede shoes.

The case is classified as an endangered missing person investigation. Theories including possible hazing have been mentioned, but no definitive evidence has emerged and it is unclear whether the three teenagers seen with him were ever identified or questioned. Does anyone have memories of that dance, the Lithuanian Dance Hall, or the people Raymond left with that night?