On the morning of May 9, 2019, 32-year-old Brian Argro was shot and killed inside his home at 5 Dorothy Road in Apalachin, New York, during a home invasion. A 20-year-old woman who was in the house was physically unharmed; Argro was found deceased in a front room of the residence. Reports say the attack was planned by a former acquaintance, Jahmier Everett of Binghamton, who recruited four men from York, Pennsylvania.

McVicker and Cuttino entered armed with a .380 pistol provided by Everett, tied up the female witness, and assaulted Argro. When Argro resisted, he was shot and killed. McVicker and Cuttino fled on foot; Cuttino was taken into custody shortly afterward on Route 434 and McVicker was arrested later that morning on a bus near New York City. Everett, Nolasco, and Turner were arrested in the months that followed.

All five men were later convicted in connection with the killing. Anyone who knew Brian Argro or has information about what happened that night is asked to come forward.