John Paciulli, 24, of Patchogue, New York, was last seen on July 10, 1971, when he went out alone to fish off Fire Island near Oak Beach and did not return. His fishing boat was later located submerged; divers recovered the vessel but John himself was never found.

Search and rescue operations were mounted after he failed to come back, but despite expanded searches of the surrounding waters and coastline no trace of him was recovered. The Suffolk County Police Department treats the matter as an unresolved disappearance: the prevailing account is that his boat was overcome by the sea, but the specific events that led to his disappearance remain unknown.

Did anyone in the Patchogue or Fire Island area have contact with John before July 10, 1971, or remember seeing his boat that day?