On July 27, 2019, 38-year-old Jason Pagan was shot and killed at the Old Timers Day celebration in Brownsville Playground, Brooklyn. The event, held near Hegeman Avenue and Sackman Street, had drawn hundreds of community members when a verbal dispute around 11 p.m. escalated into gunfire. Witnesses say a man pulled out a firearm and shot Pagan in the head and torso; that initial volley prompted a wider exchange of gunfire that wounded eleven other bystanders.

The NYPD opened an investigation and later identified a suspect after receiving tips from the community. Authorities recovered a weapon linked to the shooting, and multiple eyewitnesses identified the person who fired the first shots.

Did anyone who attended Old Timers Day that year see something that could help explain how the argument turned deadly?