On the morning of August 22, 2020, a verbal dispute in the 7-Eleven parking lot on Depot Road in Huntington Station, New York, escalated into deadly violence. Nicholas Ehrmann, 38, was confronted by 19-year-old Joshua Taylor after a brief exchange. At about 6:18 a.m. Taylor produced a handgun and fired, striking Ehrmann in the middle of Depot Road. Ehrmann was found by responding officers with a gunshot wound, taken to Huntington Hospital, and pronounced dead.

Suffolk County Police detectives identified Joshua Taylor as the person responsible and arrested him on September 8, 2020, charging him with second-degree murder. Few details are available about what was said during the initial exchange or about any witnesses who might have seen the shooting. Did anyone in Huntington Station see the argument or the shooting that morning and not yet come forward?