On the night of October 27, 2021, 28-year-old Louis Lombardo of Dix Hills was fatally shot in a garage on Murdoch Street in Huntington Station, New York. Lombardo and others were inside the garage when a separate group approached up the driveway; as those inside tried to close the garage door, a shot was fired through the door and struck Lombardo. He was taken to Huntington Hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

Investigators determined the shooting arose from a planned robbery of a marijuana dealer at the residence. Four people conspired to stage a fake deal to gain access while two others would carry out the robbery and a fifth would act as getaway driver. When the group arrived and found the garage locked, they demanded it be opened and threatened violence; one person then fired through the closed door, killing Lombardo, who was a friend of the intended victim.

Four suspects were arrested and charged: Jonray Perez, 17, of Babylon; Kayla Alvarenga, 20, of Deer Park; Jashawn Strickland, 17, of Bay Shore; and Jillian Kolsch, 20, of Smithtown. All faced second-degree murder, first-degree robbery, and conspiracy charges; Perez and Alvarenga were also charged with criminal possession of a weapon. All pleaded not guilty and were remanded without bail.

Did anyone in the Huntington Station area see or record activity on Murdoch Street that night?