On the evening of June 2, 2009, 19-year-old Shai Roxanne Caldwell was at a high school graduation party on Continental Place in Landover, Maryland, when an altercation produced a burst of gunfire. Caldwell, who was not the intended target, was struck and found lying between two parked cars; she died of her injuries on June 3, 2009. Three other people were wounded in the same shooting and survived. Caldwell was a young mother who left behind a 15-month-old daughter.

In September 2017 the Prince George’s County Police Department’s Cold Case Unit charged 27-year-old Larry Recio with first-degree murder in Caldwell’s death, saying the shooting arose from an ongoing dispute Recio had with another group at the party. Recio was already incarcerated in a federal prison in West Virginia at the time the charges were announced.

Did anyone at the party or nearby that night see what started the dispute or recognize who fired the shots?