Gary Peals was 41 when he was fatally shot on his Lentz Avenue doorstep in Louisville, Kentucky, on the evening of April 7, 2009. Peals was able to speak briefly while being taken to University Hospital, telling his fiancée he had seen the shooter at his brother’s funeral. He died shortly after arrival.

Peals’ two youngest daughters, ages three and four at the time, were inside the home and witnessed the shooting. The Louisville Metro Police Homicide Unit identified several persons of interest early on, but investigators faced limited physical evidence and few willing witnesses. The case was featured on the television series The First 48, but no arrest resulted and the investigation grew cold.

Anyone with information is asked to contact the Louisville Metro Police anonymous tip line.