Seventeen-year-old Kymmara Randolph disappeared from Orangeburg, South Carolina, on the eve of Valentine’s Day 2014 after a phone call with her mother arranging to meet later that day. A week later her body was recovered from Four Holes Swamp; she had been shot multiple times.

Investigators determined Kymmara had been with brothers Bryant McKnight and Jerry McKnight the night she vanished. Prosecutors said the brothers, believing without evidence that she had set them up to be robbed, lured her from home by saying they would take her to a party and then carried out a premeditated killing. A third man, Jonathan McKnight, was charged as an accessory after the fact. The handgun used belonged to Jerry McKnight, who was a convicted felon.

Bryant and Jerry McKnight were convicted of murder and kidnapping and received life sentences plus additional years for the kidnapping charge; Jerry also drew an extra sentence for illegal firearm possession. If anyone knew Kymmara or has information about what happened that night, please share what can help the case.