A Craigslist vehicle sale ended in violence on April 26, 2014, when 29-year-old Tycus Metricus Toland of North, South Carolina, was shot and killed at a home on Bushberry Road in Pelion. Tycus had gone with his older brother, Vonkeith Toland, 33, to show a car to two men who had responded to an online ad. Vonkeith survived after crawling under the house and later calling 911; his testimony was described as important to the investigation.

Investigators used cell phone records to identify the two men as Justin Antonio Butler, 22, of Alabama, and Terry Renee McClure, 26, of California. Butler and McClure were located in different states and subsequently charged in connection with the shootings, which also included allegations of first-degree burglary and weapons offenses. Did anyone in the Pelion or North area recognize the advertised vehicle or see the men that day?