On a September night in 1985, 16-year-old Ethan Dixon and 15-year-old Kimberly Dowell were found shot to death in the front seats of Ethan’s Volkswagen hatchback in Westside Park, Muncie, Indiana. A patrol officer clearing the park after closing discovered the idling car and the two teenagers. Both were students at Muncie Northside High School; Ethan was a junior and both were described as an all-American couple.

Investigators assigned numerous officers and followed hundreds of tips and various theories, including one involving a Dungeons & Dragons game that was later dismissed. The case went cold despite the initial investigative effort. Years later a renewed review reportedly narrowed suspicion to a single individual believed to be incarcerated for an unrelated crime, but no formal charges have been filed and the murders remain officially unsolved.

Does anyone who knew Ethan or Kimberly, or who was in Muncie that September, have information that could help bring clarity to this case?