Shortly after 2 a.m. on September 19, 2009, a burst of gunfire outside the Augusta Plaza strip mall at 71st Street and Michigan Road in Indianapolis left 29-year-old D’Angelo Antwon Toney Sr. dead. Toney, a Black male and father, was struck while standing in the parking lot with two other men, ages 36 and 25; both were critically wounded and taken to a local hospital. Toney ran a short distance after being hit and collapsed on a sidewalk, where he was pronounced dead.

Most businesses in the strip mall were closed that night except for a nightclub, and investigators examined whether there was any connection between the club and the shooting. Detectives reported multiple vehicles seen leaving the scene and planned to review surveillance footage, but officers struggled to develop solid leads and had no clear description of a shooter or shooters. No arrests or publicly identified suspects have been reported, and the case later went cold.

Anyone who knew Toney, saw activity at Augusta Plaza that morning, or has information about the shooting is asked to come forward.