Erin Ruth Justin, a 36-year-old woman from Albion, Indiana, was found dead in Bartley Lake sometime between June 21 and July 20, 2011. A fisherman discovered her body chained to a cinder block submerged in the water; the cause of death was ruled a homicide.

Investigators later developed leads that tied the killing to an assault in a garage. Court records say Andres Gonzalez Jr. picked Justin up on the evening of June 18, 2011, gave her a ride, then attacked her in his garage — striking her from behind, forcing her into a door, kicking her, grabbing her throat, and slamming her head into concrete twice. Her body was disposed of in the lake with assistance from Victor Gonzalez, who has been accused of helping remove the body.

A tip in March 2014 prompted the arrests and prosecution that followed. If anyone knew Erin, saw her in Albion in June 2011, or has information about what happened that night, please come forward.