Peter Farrell Missing Person Case

On October 13, 2019, seasoned sailor Peter Farrell, a 72-year-old man from Oakdale, New York, embarked on a solo voyage from Fire Island. Accompanied by his dog, Sunny, Farrell set sail on his 29-foot sloop, the 'Tally Ho!,' with a planned destination of Jost Van Dyke in the British Virgin Islands, and an intended stop in Bermuda. An experienced mariner and author, Farrell was well-acquainted with the route, having made the trip multiple times before. His vessel, a 1931 Atkin cutter with a dark blue hull and distinct red sails, was equipped with an Emergency Position Indicating Radio Beacon and a life raft. However, it is believed his communication equipment was limited to a VHF radio, lacking long-range options like a satellite phone or tracking device.

Concerns for Farrell's safety arose when he failed to make his customary call to family upon reaching Bermuda. The days that followed his expected arrival date of November 3rd or 4th in Jost Van Dyke turned into weeks with no word from the sailor, prompting his family to report him missing. The U.S. Coast Guard initiated an extensive search and rescue operation, covering a vast expanse of the Atlantic Ocean. Search and Rescue Optimal Planning System data was used to simulate his probable route and narrow down the search area. Despite these efforts, which spanned hundreds of thousands of square miles, no trace of Farrell, his dog, or the 'Tally Ho!' was found. The active search was eventually suspended on November 15, 2019, pending any new information.

The disappearance of Peter Farrell remains an unsolved maritime mystery. Adding a layer of complexity to the search was the discovery that Farrell had recently repainted his boat and changed its name to 'Blue Dog', a detail that was initially unclear to authorities. His sister described him as an expert seaman who had previously survived perilous situations at sea, including an incident where his boat capsized and he managed to make repairs and sail to safety. In a later development, on March 20, 2020, the EPIRB from the 'Tally Ho!' was activated approximately 1200 nautical miles east of Norfolk, Virginia, but a search of the area yielded no results. The sailing community continues to hold out hope for answers, remembering Farrell as a capable and resilient sailor. The case serves as a somber reminder of the unpredictable nature of the sea and the enduring questions that can be left in the wake of those who vanish into its depths.
Last Seen: Oct 13, 2019

In mystery of missing Long Island sailor, focus, and hope, turns to ...

Aerial search continues for missing LI sailor - Newsday

MARY JO EYTH - Oakdale Leader

Sailor Peter Farrell / SV Tally Ho Missing | SailNet Community

Mary Eyth Obituary - Resident Of Oakdale, CA (1920-2019)

Peter Farrell, 72, & dog, boat left Fire Island enroute to Jost ...