Crime Solvers Central
CSC
251 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description    (LOCATED)

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Tony Bortner, a 50-year-old fire police captain from Laurel Fire Company in Windsor, Pennsylvania, was reported missing on October 17, 2024. His disappearance was announced by the fire company on Facebook, and his vehicle was later found parked at the historic Lock 12 area in Lower Chanceford Township. Authorities searched the natural area around Lock 12, where Bortner's family mentioned he often went to clear his head.

After an extensive search, Tony Bortner's body was discovered in sh ...Read More
Last Seen: Oct 17, 2024

Victim Details

Oct 29, 2024

Oct 31, 2024

Tony

Bortner

51

50

69 inches

223 lbs

White / Caucasian

Male

In the autumn of 2024, a sense of concern rippled through York County, Pennsylvania, following the disappearance of Tony Bortner, a respected 51-year-old man from Windsor. Bortner, the Fire Police Captain for the Laurel Fire Company, was last seen on October 17, 2024. His absence was described as highly uncharacteristic, prompting his colleagues at the fire company and his family to quickly raise the alarm. Bortner was a dedicated member of his community, having joined the Laurel Fire Company in 2006 and progressively taking on more responsibility, rising from Fire Police Officer to Lieutenant, and eventually to Captain. He was known for his willingness to always help with fundraising, station chores, and mentoring younger members. The search for Tony Bortner began soon after he was reported missing. A critical lead emerged when his vehicle, a red 2008 Subaru Forester, was discovered parked at the historic Lock 12 area in Lower Chanceford Township. This location, a natural area where Bortner�s family said he often went to walk and clear his head, became the focus of an intensive search effort led by the Pennsylvania State Police, with assistance from K-9 units. The community rallied in support, sharing information and holding out hope for his safe return as days turned into weeks. Despite the extensive search of the area, there was initially no sign of the missing fire captain. Tragically, after more than two weeks of uncertainty, the search came to a sad conclusion. On November 1, 2024, Tony Bortner's body was discovered in the Susquehanna River in the Martic Township area of Lancaster County. Authorities stated there were no suspicious circumstances at the scene, and the Lancaster County Coroner's Office later confirmed that his manner of death was suicide. The news was met with profound sadness by his loved ones and the community he served with dedication for many years. The case of Tony Bortner is a heartbreaking story that began with a sudden disappearance, leading to a comprehensive search effort that unfortunately ended with the discovery of his passing, leaving a community to mourn a man remembered for his commitment to helping others.

Oct 17, 2024

Lower Chanceford Township

Pennsylvania

York County

Lower Chanceford Township

No

155607

Pennsylvania State Police York

York

Pennsylvania

York County

17403

101 North Main Street, Pennsylvania

7174281011

State

Law Enforcement

PA2024-1350172

2024-10-29

Pennsylvania State Police York

Gray or Partially Gray

Green

Green

Yes

05/14/2026


Area Last Seen: