Crime Solvers Central
CSC
251 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Phylicia Thomas, a 22-year-old woman from Sweet Valley, Pennsylvania, disappeared on the night of February 11, 2004, under suspicious circumstances. After finishing her shift at a local convenience store, the Pump-N-Pantry, she returned home around midnight. According to her boyfriend, Ed Rudaski, who was at their Lake Township residence, Phylicia asked for a beer before leaving the house again. She never returned and was reported missing shortly thereafter.

Despite extensive searches a ...Read More
Last Seen: Feb 11, 2004

Victim Details

Dec 12, 2008

Aug 08, 2022

Phylicia

Thomas

42

22

66 inches

110 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

In the quiet community of Sweet Valley, Pennsylvania, the life of 22-year-old Phylicia Albina Thomas took a bewildering turn on February 11, 2004, a day that would mark the beginning of a long and painful mystery for her family and friends. Phylicia, known as a caring individual and the oldest of seven siblings, finished her shift at a local Pump-N-Pantry convenience store between 11:30 p.m. and midnight. Her colleagues later recalled that she was in good spirits when she left. A coworker gave her a ride to the home she shared with her boyfriend, Ed Rudaski, in Lake Township. According to Rudaski, he was asleep on the couch when she arrived. He stated they had a brief exchange where she asked for a beer, and he told her it was outside on his ATV. He then went back to sleep. When he awoke about an hour later, Phylicia was gone, having vanished into the night without her purse or coat. There were no signs of a struggle or forced entry at the residence. The initial investigation into Phylicia's disappearance explored her last known movements and conversations. Both her boyfriend and the coworker who drove her home were questioned by police and cleared of any involvement. Investigators soon learned of a troubling connection to another local disappearance. Phylicia's friend, 18-year-old Jennifer Barziloski, had gone missing in 2001. Phylicia had been deeply affected by her friend's vanishing and had reportedly told her mother that she believed she knew who was responsible and was determined to prove it. This revelation cast a shadow over Phylicia�s own case, suggesting she might have gotten too close to a dangerous truth. The link between the two cases centered on a man named Steven Martin, a friend of Phylicia's boyfriend. Martin was reportedly the last person known to have seen Jennifer Barziloski before she disappeared. He claimed to have spoken with Phylicia on the phone on the night she went missing, a statement that seemed to corroborate her boyfriend's timeline. As years passed without answers, the case grew colder, though never fully dormant. Police have long suspected that foul play was involved in Phylicia's disappearance. A significant development, though tragic, came in 2010 when Jennifer Barziloski's skull was discovered in a wooded area not far from where Steven Martin had lived. Martin, however, could not be questioned further about either case. In 2005, while serving a prison sentence for an unrelated vehicular homicide that resulted in a death, he took his own life in his cell. He reportedly maintained his innocence in the disappearances of both young women until his death. Unconfirmed rumors have circulated over the years, including one that places Phylicia at a party on the night she vanished, in the company of Martin and her boyfriend, where she was allegedly lured into a bedroom before screams were heard. The case of Phylicia Thomas remains an unsolved and agonizing puzzle. Her family continues to seek answers, holding onto hope that one day they will know what happened to the young woman who disappeared after a late shift at work, leaving behind only questions and a lingering sense of loss in her community.

Feb 11, 2004

Sweet Valley

Pennsylvania

Luzerne County

17701

No

6686

Pennsylvania State Police Troop P

Hanover Township

Pennsylvania

Luzerne County

18706

Edward Urban

Detective

2001 South Valley Parkway, Pennsylvania

5708214110

State

Law Enforcement

P01-053-7166

2004-02-11

Pennsylvania State Police Troop P

5496

Brown

Blue

Blue

05/27/2026


Area Last Seen: