Crime Solvers Central
CSC
251 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Eileen Todd DeHart, aged 73, was last seen on March 15, 1975, in West Grove, Pennsylvania. On that day, her home caught fire, and after the fire was extinguished, DeHart was nowhere to be found. Initially, it was suspected that she might have wandered away due to confusion during the fire, but an extensive search of the surrounding area yielded no clues to her whereabouts. DeHart did not own a vehicle and had never learned to drive, further complicating the mystery of her disappearance.

...Read More
Last Seen: Mar 15, 1975

Victim Details

Jun 06, 2013

Mar 24, 2020

Eileen

DeHart

122

73

63 inches

100 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

In the small community of West Grove, Pennsylvania, a profound mystery began to unfold on March 15, 1975, a day that would forever alter the life of 73-year-old Eileen Todd DeHart. On this particular day, Eileen, a white female with gray hair and blue eyes, was last seen in her hometown. The circumstances of her last known moments are tied to a catastrophic event that struck her residence. Standing at 5-feet-3-inches and weighing approximately 100 pounds, Eileen was known to walk with a noticeable unsteadiness due to a previously fractured leg. This physical characteristic, coupled with the fact that she had never learned to drive and did not own a vehicle, adds a layer of complexity to the events that followed. The day after Eileen was last seen, a fire engulfed her home on March 16, 1975. Once the flames were finally extinguished and the smoke cleared, a startling and grim discovery was made; Eileen was nowhere to be found. In the initial stages of the investigation, authorities considered the possibility that she may have become disoriented and wandered off in the chaos and confusion of the fire. However, as extensive searches of the surrounding area were conducted, no trace of Eileen was uncovered, and no one had heard from her since. The lack of any evidence pointing to her whereabouts deepened the mystery of her sudden disappearance. The investigation into Eileen DeHart's vanishing has spanned decades, yet it remains an unsolved case with no definitive answers. The Pennsylvania State Police have maintained her case file, classifying her as an endangered missing person. The perplexing circumstances, a house fire followed by a complete disappearance, have left her loved ones and the community with lingering questions. Without any further evidence or leads surfacing over the years, the case has grown cold. The official narrative remains that she disappeared after the fire at her home, leaving behind a legacy of uncertainty and a family still hoping for resolution.

Mar 15, 1975

West Grove

Pennsylvania

Chester County

17390

No

13664

Pennsylvania State Police

Avondale

Pennsylvania

Chester County

19311

Henry Callithen III

Criminal Investigation Assessment Unit

2 Moxley Lane, Pennsylvania

6102682022

State

Law Enforcement

J02-5640

1975-03-16

Pennsylvania State Police

Gray or Partially Gray

Blue

Blue

05/27/2026


Area Last Seen: